bookish posts reviews

An Inheritance of Ashes by Leah Bobet

inheritance of ashesVery occasionally, in the midst of all the other books, you come across one that feels like it was written literally and specifically for you. An Inheritance of Ashes is one of those books for me. As such–fair warning–the rest of this post is not even going to be remotely unbiased.

There are several things that An Inheritance of Ashes has going for it. I  loved the richness of the language; it’s a marvelous combination of realistic (and often funny) dialogue, and poetic prose without a misplaced word. The book opens like this: “The barley was in. The stubble of it lay bent-broke in the fields as far as the eye could see, rows of golden soldiers, endlessly falling, from the river to the blacktop road. On a clear evening, with the harvesting done, you could see both river and road from the farmhouse porch: every acre, lined in sunset light, of Roadstead Farm.” It’s lovely to read, and on re-reading it just now, I caught so many echoes that we’ll see later on in the book.

But while language is certainly important, for me as a reader characters will make or break a book. And here they make it. I cared about all of them: Marthe, and Heron, and Asphodel Jones. Even the more minor characters read as rounded and vibrant in their own right. As I think about it, I suspect that this is quite intentional; that we are supposed to see all of these people as real and important.

However, Hallie, our narrator, is central to this story. We have a tight first person narration here; we see everything through her eyes, through her experiences, and personality, and biases. Bobet is quite aware of this and plays with it throughout the book. While I wouldn’t say that Hallie is exactly an unreliable narrator, we are reminded several times that her point of view is not the only one.

Hallie’s voice is clear and strong and wonderful. She is neither perfect nor passive. She reads as very human: flawed, stubborn, contradictory, full of hope and fear and wanting to love. I completely and utterly believed in her.

The other area where An Inheritance of Ashes really shone for me was in the themes. Partly this is personal–the way Hallie and Marthe’s family is described, the way they struggle to deal with that past while not letting it define them, the way they don’t always succeed–all of that rang so familiar and so true that it felt almost eerie. It moved me to tears several times. I kept thinking, “Yes. This is how it is. This is how it feels. This is how I feel.”

But as well as this aspect, I also truly appreciated the way the book shows the importance of relationships, that our strength lies in each other. That it lies in reaching out, beyond all hope (a little bit of Cordelia Vorkosigan there, maybe). And again there’s that moment when Hallie’s perspective is shown to be limited, when the twists of the past are finally unknotted and we see, with her, a different truth. It might not have worked, but here it does, and it reinforces the idea that by reaching towards others, we can find our own strength.

Finally, I’ll mention that I found the worldbuilding and imagery here fantastic, and gorgeous, and scary, in all the right ways. There’s a lot of depth and richness to the images and the way they tie into the worldbuilding. I really felt that sense of history lying behind the story that we don’t see but that informs everything else.

I’m so glad that the Cybils gave me a reason to pick this one up; it’it will absolutely be one of my favorite books for the year, and one I intended to re-read regularly.

Book information: 2015, Clarion Books; YA

Book source: review copy from the publisher provided for the Cybils


Other reviews: The Midnight Garden, Teen Reads, Kirkus, you?

If you like this book, you may also be interested in:

Chime by Franny Billingsley
Tess of the Road by Rachel Hartman
The Winged Histories by Sofia Samatar
The Imperial Raadch series by Ann Leckie



By Maureen LaFerney

My name is Maureen. I currently work as a library assistant in a public library in the Indianapolis area, and also just so happen to be a voracious reader. I frequently end up under a cat.

9 replies on “An Inheritance of Ashes by Leah Bobet”

I added this to my wishlist when I saw you mention it as a favorite on Twitter. Your review just made me want to read it sooner. I’m also a character reader and my enjoyment of a book depends on how much I like the characters.

[…] An Inheritance of Ashes by Leah Bobet: This book took me somewhat by surprise; I had heard good things about it, but I wasn’t expecting to love it as much as I did. I wasn’t expecting to find a story that touched me so deeply personally. When I step back, I can see that it does a number of things that I love: setting is so important, it’s a story after the war ends, the language is poetic but not overblown, and the characters are complex. But really I don’t want to step back; I want to hold it close forever. […]

I remember seeing this review earlier and skimming it to avoid any spoilers, in case there were any, because I meant to read the book… Now I’ve read it and I’ve come back. It was gorgeous and awesome and exactly my kind of thing as well. I love the groundedness, the way the huge events were brought down to a very individual level, the casually multiracial and -cultural population of the world, the very subtle postapocalyptic setting (it was halfway through the book at least before I realized!) and really, so many other things. I hope this book wins lots of awards, but most of all that lots of people find it.

What a lovely comment! Thank you! Yes, it’s really well done, and so heartening in a certain way.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.