Xenocide–Orson Scott Card

I have been reading the Ender and Bean series because I started them long ago and I am a completeist. I finished the Bean series and then I read Speaker for the Dead and Xenocide, so I’d be reading in terms of internal chronology. The Bean series I liked just fine as what they are–action sci-fi. The Ender series are something else entirely.

I love Ender’s Game. I’ve read it several times and each time I have the same emotional response to it. It’s a book I’m happy to say is a favorite. But the sad truth is, the series as a whole suffers from what I have dubbed “Amber Spyglass syndrome”. You know, the first book is amazing, and you can’t wait to read the rest of the series. And then the second book isn’t exactly what you expected, and you’re not sure you entirely trust where the author is going, but surely the third book will be great. And then you read the third book and you are totally disappointed and a little bit stabby because good GRIEF, it’s nothing but opinions and philosophy with a very thin veneer of story over it and moreover, the characters you’ve grown to love are just gone.

*takes a deep breath*

So that’s what I see going on with Xenocide. Card has substituted philosophy for story and the result is an odd and unsatisfying book. I appreciate the difficulties Card is facing in terms of trying to write science fiction as a person of faith. But as someone who is also religious, I also really dislike what he does here, just as much as I dislike what Pullman does in Amber Spyglass. It’s not even good science fiction–the solution to the problem is some alchemical combination of magic and religion and philosophy. It’s a solution to f-t-l travel, and so it takes on a classic sci-fi problem, but in a way that I–not at all a scientist–found both aggravating and suspect.

Moreover, I felt distanced from Ender, which I never have before. I never necessarily liked or agreed with all his actions and stances, but I always cared for him. Xenocide‘s Ender is not the Ender I cared about. The characters even refer to him mostly as Andrew, which doesn’t help.

So it’s frustrating and I now have to decide whether to go on, if I should finish the series or give the whole thing up as a bad job. It’s a tough call and I haven’t made it yet. But I know that I’m annoyed with the moralizing and philosophy masquerading as story.

Book source: public library

Book information: 1996, Tor; adult science fiction (YA crossover)

Advertisements

6 Comments

Filed under bookish posts, reviews

6 responses to “Xenocide–Orson Scott Card

  1. caitlin

    I see what you mean about the philosophizing/political ruminating turn the latter books of the series take. But somehow, Xenocide was still always my favorite of the trilogy, or at least tied with Ender’s Game. I only read the fourth book of that series once–and it was even more political and less plot driven than SftD & X, so I’d say no, it’s not worth finishing up the series.

    • Maureen E

      Interesting! I don’t mind politics–heck, I love the Vorkosigan books with are at least 40% politics if not more–but I do need a personal entrance into them, and that’s what was missing I think. But I’ll probably at least check out the last book and see how far I get.

  2. Kim

    Eh, I read them all back in HS. You know I love Ender’s Game, and I did really love Speaker for the Dead as well, but it definitely went downhill from there. I don’t think I’ve re-read any of the rest since then, which tells you something. That being said, I understand the feeling of wanting to see how it ends.

    Also, if you want to read more by Card, I highly recommend The Worthing Saga.

  3. Pingback: November 2012-January 2013 reading list | By Singing Light

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s