Summing up

I’ve been doing too much book reading and not enough reviewing, again. And so, though I dislike doing it, I’m going to go all Inigo Montoya (“Let me explain. No, there is too much. Let me sum up.”). I feel like I’ll be doing a disservice to some of the books I talk about by not going on at more length. Here we are anyway.

1. The Spy in the House by Y.S. Lee: I first heard about this series from Leila when she posted about the making of the covers. I looked at them and, being a bit of a costume history buff, was gleeful. Accurate clothing? On a cover for a Victorian book? YAY! So I went in with high hopes. And I wasn’t disappointed. The book is light on the one hand, although it’s also clearly written by someone who knows her stuff. On the other hand, it doesn’t shy away from talking about the tragedies of Victorian life. AND I absolutely loved the fact that the characters, even the ones with somewhat radical beliefs, didn’t feel like modern people shoved uncomfortably into the past. Their reactions felt of a piece with their times. And isn’t the cover gorgeous?

2. Factotum by D.M. Cornish: Third book in the Foundling’s Tale/Monster Blood Tattoo trilogy. I’m constantly amazed at the breadth of vision in these books. I felt like I could reach out and touch the Half-Continent. I found myself thinking a lot about influences with this one. In some ways it felt very European–the whole baroqueness of it–and in others it’s not at all what I’d expect from a European based fantasy.* I suppose this could be related to the fact that Cornish is Australian. I did find myself a bit sad at the end, but it was the kind of sadness that felt right, and I can’t quite imagine another possible ending. I do hope we get more stories from the Half-Continent though.
* By this I’m referring more to setting than to nationality of author.

3. The Folk Keeper by Franny Billingsley: Here is as pretty a case of mis-marketing as you could mention. From my initial glances at the front cover, I expected something sort of young and cute. That’s not the case at all. Instead, the story is shadowy and haunting, the writing absolutely gorgeous. It needs a new cover to market it to the YA crowd, because I didn’t find it juvenile at all, but the cover says that’s what it is. Definitely one for the Patricia McKillip fans out there.

4. A Coalition of Lions by Elizabeth Wein: And then I went on an Elizabeth Wein re-reading kick. I left out The Winter Prince, which I’d re-read quite recently and which always feels like it’s only tenuously part of the series anyway. (I don’t mean that as a criticism at all–just that I’m in a different mood when I read it than when I read the rest.) I love Goewin, who continues to be a fantastic character. The sense of being trapped between bad decisions and trying to find a way through them is very strong here. And, finally, Camlann makes me sad. (Authors are mean people. I may have mentioned this before.)

5. The Sunbird by Elizabeth Wein: The main focus switches from Goewin to Telemakos in this book. And I love Telemakos. I love this book too, in a way I think I didn’t the first time I read it. The political tensions, the relationship between the plague and salt, the characters. There are so many echoes back to the first book, which made me think about the characters in such a new way. Probably my favorite of these is when Telemakos tells Medraut that the salt looks like snow–the brief description there had such a vivid ties to the description of the snow in The Winter Prince, and it provides a glimpse into Medraut’s mind that we’re lacking at that point in the story.

6. The Lion Hunter by Elizabeth Wein: Here are my notes for the first part of this book, verbatim. “Telemakos! I love you! And I kind of want to smack every adult around you, even though usually I love Medraut-well, maybe not Goewin.” Yes, a lot of Telemakos love here. I mean, how could I not love a small, sneaky Aksumite/British prince? As with The Sunbird, I really noticed the many moments that resonate with earlier books, especially Winter Prince. As I finished this book and went on into the next I thought about the fact that Abreha is like Medraut, and wondered if he was also like Artos, since Medraut often reminds me of his father.

7. The Empty Kingdom by Elizabeth Wein: The answer to my question: yes, Abreha is quite a bit like Artos, punishing but also forgiving (and the parallels to Eugenides are somewhat startling, yes). Given Abreha’s demonstrated admiration for Artos, it makes sense. This is one of those books where I know that I’ll never be in Telemakos’s exact situation, and yet I felt like I learned something. Favorite line: ”borne down by the weight of his name”–oh, I love that. After the re-read, I wanted more. I could be content with the series as it stands, because they are all fantastic books and in fact are one of those rare series that gets better as it grows, but I’d also love to have more of Telemakos’s story. It’s pretty clear that there’s more to tell, and I’m a greedy reader.

8. The Curse of Chalion by Lois McMaster Bujold: I love what I tend to think of as historical fantasies, at least when they’re done right. Basically, it’s any sort of fantasy with some historical background in our world. This is possibly my favorite type–the kind which takes the feeling of a particular time and place, more than the specific historical details. And the characters are great. Cazaril was a likable and believable protagonist and Iselle and Beatriz were just lovely. So another win from Bujold.

9. Cryoburn by Lois McMaster Bujold: I don’t have a lot to say about this one. I mean, yay Miles, as always. My Barrayaran prejudice continues; I enjoyed the story, but felt that the heart of it came at the end. Speaking of which WAAAAH. I even knew it was coming, thanks to an accidental spoiler in Wikipedia, but I still bawled quarts. Especially at Gregor’s bit. (Have I mentioned that my massive literary crush on Miles tops my massive literary crush on Gregor by only a little bit?) So obviously, I’m hoping for a Barrayaran book as the next one. Speaking of which, I do feel that the end of this book could really rival the beginning of Memory in terms of changing the tenor of the series.

Proper reviews on a few more coming soon!


Filed under bookish posts, reviews

16 responses to “Summing up

  1. Oooh an Elizabeth Wein re-read! I really should do that soon so I could review the books on my blog. I only reviewed Sunbird a while back. I keep telling people to read her books because Telemakos is awesome, but I don’t think anyone has picked up the books because of my recommendation.

  2. From my initial glances at the front cover, I expected something sort of young and cute.
    RIGHT?? I even found it in the juvenile section of the library where I checked it out.

    When I was searching for a good version of the cover image for my post, I stumbled upon this awesome Australian edition
    which manages to be both very charming and extremely creepy.

    Anyway, glad you enjoyed it as much as I did!

    • Maureen E

      Yeah, seriously! I’m actually glad I had read your review first because otherwise I don’t know that I would have enjoyed the book as much. I like the Australian cover, but I think I really want Kinuko Craft to do one, just because she manages to do such an awesome job with P. McKillip’s.

  3. Pingback: April 2012 book list | By Singing Light

  4. Pingback: Elizabeth Wein | By Singing Light

  5. Pingback: Favorite Authors: Franny Billingsley | By Singing Light

  6. Pingback: Historical Fantasies: Medieval and Renaissance Europe | By Singing Light

  7. Pingback: Top Ten Tuesday: Best sequels | By Singing Light

  8. Pingback: Lois McMaster Bujold | By Singing Light

  9. Pingback: Historical Fantasies: Elizabethan/Baroque/Georgian | By Singing Light

  10. Pingback: Top Ten Tuesday: Books for people who haven’t read historical fantasy | By Singing Light

  11. Pingback: Historical Fantasies: Victorian era | By Singing Light

  12. Pingback: Paladin of Souls: a review | By Singing Light

  13. Pingback: Chime: a review | By Singing Light

Leave a Reply to Maureen E Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.